place watch credit report free credit report all 3 bureaus without debit card instant single credit report three credit bureau reporting agencies scores consumer reports credit score report equifax free credit report usaa how long does it take to remove credit report how to report bad tenant to credit agency security freeze all credit reports only real free credit report fair reviews on credit repair gurus project report on credit appraisal system free annual credit report form payday loans online same day canada credit report federal trade commission free credit report all 3 credit bureau experian fast speedy cash online reviews how long does it take for bankruptcy to clear from credit report credit report less than 30 days late ways to repair your credit rating order copy of credit report business all 3 free credit reports and scores soft hard pull credit report which is the best place to get a credit report my 1 free credit report year best way remove collections credit report bank america credit report govt sponsored free credit report online gov annual credit report free increase what is a good credit score canada annual free credit report new york state best score reporting company credit card bad credit loans canada reviews installment loans that report to credit bureau free credit report fico score free transunion credit report online local credit watch repair in leesburg va landlord report late rent to credit bureau how do you read a credit bureau report how do i check my free credit report houston credit repair agency reviews equifax free yearly credit report free credit report song chords credit report dispute form doc mortgage companies required report credit bureaus free credit report under fair credit reporting act fcra remove negative report credit report does free credit report have fico score equifax canada online credit report south africa bureau report free checking your credit rating can anyone pull your credit report can youtube get your credit report free date last activity credit report canada credit repair printing company in new orleans removing negative items from credit report after 7 years dispute credit report letter example equifax free credit score information how to find credit how to find credit score on credit report transunion credit reporting mailing address free rent business reporting to credit bureaus 2010 credit suisse global wealth report pdf will eviction notice appear my credit report cbc credit report login ce credit report 24.95 credit report costco credit report form letter safe check my credit report online free credit report from credit bureau south africa legal right free credit report credit home repair programs in philadelphia free credit report government agency how to fix an error on your credit report free 3 and 1 credit report free credit report credit card required credit repair family law attorney richmond va can lender give copy credit report borrower how do you dispute credit report information need help reading my credit report request credit score under fair credit reporting act 3 credit reports scores online free credit report transunion mail free credit credit report free credit report rap commercial 2014 credit reporting agency notification how to dispute credit report for experian com experian free yearly credit report credit card reports all 3 credit bureaus how to report owner financing to credit bureaus equifax free credit report yearly why is my credit score not on my credit report canadian personal credit reports credit report letter of dispute federal trade commision free annual credit report website free one off credit report annual credit report no score how do i get my 1 free credit report consumer reports credit repair services landlord ordering credit reports often can run my credit report bank of america credit reporting department phone number credit report 1b score can you really get a free credit report how do me get your free credit report each year free credit reports and scores from 3 bureau address transunion credit reports free business credit reports scores how dog i get my free credit report from all three bureaus my free yearly credit report score equifax number order credit report free credit report score all three bureaus experian order credit report mail transunion cis credit reporting agency best way to fix my credit report chase checking credit report account online best credit reporting service credit reporting agency phone numbers fa credco on credit report freeze my credit report florida obtain your credit report australia credit report review certification update my experian credit report credit agricole corporate and investment bank annual report 2009 prospera credit union 2010 annual report best real cash advances online equifax credit report free annual dispute debt credit reporting agencies free credit report reporting agency experian what are soft inquiries on your credit report how safe is annual credit report site free yearly credit report 2010 transunion view equifax credit report free rebuild experian credit score uk credit report for tenant request a copy of my credit report how to unfreeze my credit report equifax ben stein credit report letter explanation inquiry credit report how do i clear defaults off my credit report credit report business account free credit report your entitled under federal law how to request free credit reports by mail free credit report website safe equifax free credit report contact number bureau collection agency not reporting credit agency check my annual credit report for free how to get a paid medical bill off credit report fix error my credit report canada credit report repair service experian denied credit report what are the three major credit reporting bureaus credit union annual reports best credit report service 2011 collection agency credit report credit royalty free images get free credit report mailed you put security freeze credit reports credit report customer service credit line report instant credit report score day trial how to remove inquiries from your credit report state employees credit union free credit report kroll credit report 3in1 credit report fico score request equifax credit report by mail credit report equifax credit score range chart get credit inquiries off credit report the best credit reporting agencies how do i order a credit report on someone how to get one free credit report a year free annual credit report federal law copy checking your credit report online address for the 3 reporting bad credit agencies free free yearly credit check report annual report credit agricole 2010 reporting agencies free annual report credit score what are the names of the three main national credit report companies how do you dispute an item on your credit report experian credit report charges tips disputing items your credit report federal fair credit report act new free credit report commercial 2014 remove dispute off your credit report how to request free annual credit report online credit reports free law quick fix to improve credit score write dispute letter credit report agencies what is credit report freeze what is a statutory credit report how long to update credit report obtain free copy your credit report major free credit report experian transunion equifax transunion credit reporting company update your credit report fast will collection agency remove credit report the fair credit weather modification reporting act of 1972 government credit report free first premier credit report collections on credit report tips ordering credit report can i get a credit report with an itin how to monitor credit report how can i obtain a free credit report equifax us government credit report annual instant tenant credit reports credit report charge off removal top credit reporting agencies contact 3 major credit reporting agencies aaa member credit report chapter 7 how long on credit report trw free credit report experian unlimited credit report access free visa report after denied credit transunion dispute your credit report transunion how do i get a free credit report length bankruptcy credit report canada get free credit report irs consumers credit report inquiry letter can payday loans go on your credit report happened guy free credit report commercial singer all 3 credit score reports commission on credit unions report add employment information credit report online payday loans with no credit check or employment verification stop unauthorized inquiries credit report free credit report no credit card payment can;t get free credit report from transunion how to get a copy of free credit report start a credit credit repair business at home rels credit report my free annual report transunion credit history company credit card credit report how to get the credit reports for free long does take judgement clear your credit report totally free credit reports and scores complaint under fair credit reporting act 3 bureau credit report 3 plus scores how do u check your credit report free your free credit report see my credit report pull credit reports landlord sovereign debt credit risk report call for free credit report canada annual credit report login example letter explanation credit report does checking my credit report hurt my credit score new york state resident free credit report correcting a bad credit report erroneous credit report information quizzles free credit report credit report triple score military online pay advance loans when are you entitled to a free copy of your credit report 3 free credit reports online suze orman credit report site get credit report trw cibil (credit information bureau (india) limited) report comprehensive credit report cash advance today orem utah newspaper singapore credit report personal experian free credit report contact who is the band in the free credit report.com commercials who can check my credit report credit card purchases exempt 1099 reporting what's a good credit score 2014 phone number all three credit reports get all 3 scores and reports free credit do inaccurate credit report best place obtain free credit report free credit report score yearly free credit report vs fico score how often can i get a free credit report from quizzle credit report score formula how to dispute credit report online for free medical credit report collection items credit repair do it yourself free wall bed plans telephone number to order credit report lexisnexis ins p&c credit report free report transunion without card credit check does getting a credit report hurt score federal free credit report gov entitled how to get a paid state tax lien removed from credit report transunion annual credit report problems credit reports australia most accurate credit reporting agency govt sponsored free credit report consumers how long does collections stay on my credit report new free credit report commercial future credit bureau reporting software agencies report on manufactures and report on the public credit how can i get a copy of my credit report free instant online credit report how do i obtain a free credit report and score credit agricole corporate and investment bank annual report 2011 paid medical collections on credit report credit report ontario free credit report no card details required credit report official site legit credit report websites experian free report uk credit rating experian credit report freeze top 3 report sites credit rating fair credit reporting act+consumer credit unsecured credit cards that report to all three credit bureaus get free report canada without card bad credit reading and understanding a credit report credit reporting agencies dispute contact information transunion credit report free credit monitoring arrangement rbi long does debt settlement remain credit report when does discover card report to credit bureau get medical collection removed credit report free copy my credit report experian us credit report centers how to unfreeze my equifax credit report credit union 5300 call reports how often should you pull your credit report payday loans direct lender bad credit uk how how do i know if i place a freeze on my credit report how to understand equifax credit report how to read reading a credit report score sample letter fix credit report bankruptcy credit report how long 3 bureau credit report free trial absolutely free credit report online report stolen chase credit cards working tax credit from april 2012 how long chapter 13 on credit report experian denied credit free report fico equifax credit scores ranges denied credit get free credit report equifax how to report payment history to credit bureau get free credit report free credit report how to how to read your credit report score how can you improve your credit report change address for credit reports wipe clean your credit report quizzles credit report ll bureaus how to check credit report for a minor texas free credit report annual free credit report issues 3 free credit report year credit report one time free how do you get rid of how to get a credit card with a bad credit rating paid debt still on credit report my year free credit report how long delinquency stay on credit report actual credit report get fico score credit report what are the 3 types of credit reports repair my credit report fast free visa report due denied credit equifax transunion credit report iif denied credit get yearly free credit reports what is kd on your credit report toyota credit revenue canada contact information order a copy of my credit report buy credit report one time s&p credit rating explained how do i get my credit score from my credit report article fair credit reporting act violations can paid collections be removed from credit report consumer reports credit cards for students free credit report commercial pirate hat fair free annual credit report from govt easy credit report consumer disputes this account information credit report from transunion get safe credit report free score and report experian credit history letter remove collections credit report how to lock down credit report free experian credit report online how to make a credit report dispute how to repair your credit score on your own credit auto repair west columbia sc annual credit report fha home loan credit score needed dispute item equifax credit report 3 credit what are the credit reporting agencies in canada what kind of information does a credit report contain capital one credit capital one credit card cash advance fees dispute on credit report online chapter 7 bankruptcy and credit report reasons you can dispute your credit report how do i repair my fixing your credit with charge offs equifax buy credit report one time best company to get credit report from online online payday advances direct lenders credit report all bureau transunion can you get inquiries removed from credit report chase identity protection credit report collections remove from credit report how to get my credit report free annually how to remove debt collection from credit report how to read credit report how to remove a bankruptcy from your credit report after 7 years totally free credit report and score no credit card required credit cards report authorized users annual credit report score cost how to read credit report scores dispute items equifax credit report online experian credit report dispute forms how to remove judgements on credit report does landlord need run credit report who sings the free credit report dot com commercials experian corporate credit report all 3 credit score report transunion once a one time a year free credit report view all three credit reports free request a credit report from bank free credit report canada review equifax what happened to the free credit report.com band best way to fix your credit report how to obtain a credit report in canada for free get experian credit report online get all three credit reports and scores credit score report singapore how can i remove charge offs from credit report get dun bradstreet credit report there actually free credit report credit report rating r1 credit report codes m credit report protection clean your credit report up best place free credit report file complaint free credit report my free yearly credit report should your credit report cost you job best place to pull credit report free copy my credit report canada credit cards reporting check free credit report equifax ca check review free credit reports canada should put security freeze my credit report tenant credit reporting free credit report federal trade fair credit reporting act notice disclosure fake credit report sites why is there a security freeze on my credit report does paid profit loss mean credit report can collections be removed from your credit report credit annual report how to report to experian credit agency credit report credit karma getting your credit report corrected credit reporting agency does chase bank use long does collection agency stay credit report how do you get a real free credit report tenant credit reports for realtors view all credit reports freeware how do you obtain your free credit report bureaus free credit card report how to get my view credit report free online credit report scams on craigslist list of credit credit rating agency in india legal credit report credit report score all three bureaus how do you order a free credit report view my free credit report veda credit report disputing a credit report with experian how quickly does my credit report get updated how to dispute an error on your credit report credit report federal website credit report and score one time payment government free credit report yearly transunion credit report free credit report do disputes show on credit report free 3 credit reporting agencies how to get all 3 credit reports for free what are charged off accounts on credit report free credit report gove canada how to change information on a credit report how often can i get a free credit report buy house foreclosure your credit report fast credit repair scores top ten credit reporting agencies check credit credit history nz request for free credit report for equifax copy of credit report if denied credit get free credit report without free trial long does debt stay your credit report two major credit bureaus how do i find out what i owe on my credit report time limit reporting bad credit free credit report no credit card info cic ce credit report phone number free credit report lyrics cell phone three credit reports score commercial credit report sample free credit report commercial members his band can you remove a charge off from your credit report unfair credit reporting act does checking tour credit report lower your score dispute credit report by phone canada legal credit repair services what does transferred to recovery mean on my credit report consumer reports best credit card dun and bradstreet commercial credit report certified credit report fcra federal
Home Biz of Baseball - Interviews Interview - Andrew Zimbalist - Sports Economist

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1346 guests online

Atom RSS

Interview - Andrew Zimbalist - Sports Economist PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 4
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Sunday, 08 August 2004 12:00

Andrew ZimbalistWhen the discussion of the economics of baseball are discussed in the media and beyond, most often you'll find Andrew Zimbalist in the mix.

This interview covers the debate over the public subsidy of stadium development, to territorial rights, especially as it pertains to the Baltimore/Washington, D.C. area, to the current revenue sharing system, plus more, Zimbalist covers all the bases.


The numbers are staggering.

Since 1992, when Bud Selig took over as Commissioner of Baseball, there have been 15 new or renovated ballparks. In the case of the new ballparks, all have had some form of public subsidy involved, totaling well in excess of a billion dollars when all is said and done and leases are fulfilled. This new stadium development is touted by MLB as being a panacea towards overall franchise success, regardless of the fact that many see franchise sustainability being coupled, in large part, to wins and losses as well.

With this large volume of stadia development has been the constant struggle to try to quantify the economic impacts of ballpark development within local, state and regional domains, and one of the most visible economists to speak to this current environment has been Andrew Zimbalist.

Zimbalist serves as Robert A. Woods Professor of Economics at Smith College and his resume is  peppered with consultation as it pertains to baseball. To Wendell, Chritton & Parks in the Florida State League/Florida Marlins arbitration case, to the Major League Baseball Players' Association in collective bargaining, to ABRY Communications in a baseball broadcasting suit, to the United Baseball League, to Krendl, Horowitz and Krendl in Ehrhardt v. Colorado Rockies, to the Portland Oregon Mayor's Commission on bringing another professional sports team to the city, the list is far too long to mention in this space.

To add to this, Andrew has several outstanding books on the economics of baseball. "Baseball and Billions: A Probing Look Inside the Big Business of Our National Pastime", and "May the Best Team Win: Baseball Economics and Public Policy" can be found on the desks of those ranging from politicians, to fellow economists, to baseball researchers.

The following interview covers several areas, from the economics of new stadium development, to the shifting of discretionary income as it pertains to this development, to the territorial claims by Orioles owner Peter Angelos regarding the possible relocation of the Montreal Expos to Washington, D.C., and possible ramifications to further relocation or expansion, to the overall health of small to mid-tiered markets under the current revenue sharing plan. Enjoy! - Maury Brown


BizBall: You’ve been following the economics of baseball for some time now. What has been the biggest fundamental change in how MLB conducts business over the last 10-20 years?

Zimbalist:
I would think that the biggest change has been the introduction of its revenue sharing system in 1996 and the extension of that system in 2002. Prior to that system the only thing that got shared in baseball was gate revenue. And in the American League they shared about 20% of gate revenue, and the National League about 5% of gate revenue. There was a program that they introduced in the 80’s to do some sharing in the American League of pay cable back then, but basically it amounted to just about nothing. So fundamentally out of all the revenue that got generated they only had either the 20% [shared] in the American League and roughly 5% in the National League; nothing else was shared.

And then when local television contracts really began to take off -- the Yankee contract that was signed with MSG back in 1988 was a 12 year contract worth $493 million over the period -- you had the emergence of TBS with the Braves and WGN with the Cubs, and the Mets had a big contract, the Red Sox got a big contract, baseball’s revenues became very sharply imbalanced.

And, the other thing that’s happening of course in the early 90’s is the introduction of the new stadiums, beginning with Camden Yards, or some people might want to date it to a year earlier in 1991 with the new White Sox stadium. But the retro-set architecture stadiums begins with ‘92 Camden Yards. Those stadiums for many teams ended up generating an extra $30 million a year for the team, so that together with the local television contracts and no revenue sharing meant that the revenue disparities between top and the bottom teams, which were actually no greater than $30 million back in 1989, all of the sudden exploded, so that by the end of the 90’s those disparities are up over $200 million. Or around $200 million, let’s say.

And in this context baseball introduced the revenue sharing system. I think it’s a really major change. It required a shift in political alignments, to get the big city teams to go along with that, to get Steinbrenner to go along with that, O’Malley at the time still owned the Dodgers, to get him to go along with it in ’96, to get the Chicago teams to go along with it, the Tribune Corporation, was a major political accomplishment. And they began sharing revenues, so I think that’s the big number, and of course as I’ve said elsewhere the system doesn’t work as well as it ought to because the incentives that are built into it are perverse, they’re backwards, they actually assess a higher marginal tax rate on low revenue teams than on high revenue teams. It therefore in my view has not done what it is supposed to do, which is to equalize payrolls.

BizBall: A common claim among economists is that spending on sports simply shifts spending from other entertainment options (movies, etc.). This theory assumes that most individuals have a finite amount of discretionary income to spend on entertainment. Some might argue that a high percentage of Americans have enough discretionary income to choose to attend most of the entertainment events that they would like to attend. If season ticket holders of an MLB team suddenly lost their franchise, would it follow that each season ticket holder would add 81 nights of other entertainment activities annually to their life?

Zimbalist: [laughter] Well, first of all, I don’t think that season ticket holders go to all 81 games. Most of them don’t, anyway; I think they end up sharing their ticket, or giving away their ticket to some other people, at least for some of the games. But no, I don’t think it follows that way, and look, I don’t think the proper argument is that there is a 1-to-1 trade off here. The argument is simply that for most people who go to ballgames they have a finite amount of discretionary income and there is a substitution effect working, but again, it’s not a 1-to-1 effect, maybe it effects 80% or 90% of the money that would otherwise get spent at the ballpark.
And it certainly is not the only basis for the argument that there is no positive economic impulse or developmental impulse from having a new stadium or a new team in your town.

One of the reasons is the substitution effect, but another very important reason is the leakage effect. Which is to say that if money gets spent at a ballpark, something like 60% of it on average goes to players, who have an average income of $2.4 million, and when money goes to those players, and most players don’t live in the town where their team is anyway, then the money leaks out, because a millionaire has a very high savings rate, much higher savings rate than somebody with ordinary income, thirty or forty thousand dollars, and that money they save goes into the world money markets, it doesn’t get spent at the local cities, and even more that’s true because the player doesn’t live in the city, so his permanent home is elsewhere, or if he has family elsewhere, a lot of the money gets sent back to the family.

And, also players are encouraged, and most of them follow the encouragement or the advice, they’re encouraged to save a lot because their life in baseball and their lifetime earning the mega-salaries is a very short one.

It’s not like what happens to me, an economics professor. I got into the business of being an economics professor when I was 25 years old and I could do that for decades, but for professional baseball players if you’re lucky you play 5 to 10 years and you don’t earn the mega-salaries your whole life. So, they’re encouraged to save a lot of money, and again the pattern is for the money to go into the world money markets and not to be spent in the local cities. So, there are leakages. And, of course, a lot of money goes to the owners and the owners have a similar pattern to the players, and those leakages are much higher than if the entertainment dollar gets spent at the bowling alley or restaurants, where the money ultimately goes to entrepreneurs who have a much more normal income, and who live in the local towns. So, very high leakages are another factor here. And, another factor still is that ballparks these days get financed with hundreds of millions of dollars of local tax money and if taxes go up then it means that that money is not being spent by consumers in other areas of the local economy. Either that or the city might rig -- I guess I’m not sure about this --either the services, and either higher taxes or lower services doesn’t help the local economy. So, if you put all of those effects together, the empirical research suggests that the expectation should not be that you get an increase in employment or an increase in per capita income.

BizBall: What about in cases where there are personal income taxes in some states? Wouldn’t there be money collected from the players and management in that framework?

Zimbalist: Yeah, there would be, but again the evidence is that the amount of expenditure that goes out of the public coffers in order to finance the debt service that they have to incur to build the stadium, or to improve the infrastructure, or both of those things, the amount of outflow is greater than the amount of inflow.

BizBall: Along the same lines, in the case of several cities, and possibly some new locations should relocation or expansion be considered, there are cities that border other states. Is there a case to be made that monies from bordering states cross over into these locales and therefore help the economies of these host cities via tourism?

Zimbalist: Yeah, sure, and in fact I made that case in part with the New York Nets leaving New Jersey and going into New York, in this case Brooklyn. So it can happen.

There are possibilities for, in essence, cannibalizing revenue across state lines.

And if what you’re interested in is the fiscal situation of a government on one side of the state line as opposed to the other side of the state line, yeah, there can be a shift in that way. It doesn’t end up producing a tremendous amount of difference, but there can be a small gain as a result of that.

It’s a different argument than an argument for regional development, though, because in terms of the overall metropolitan area the money is still in that area. But it might very well cross a political boundary and help one side of the boundary to the detriment to the other side.

BizBall: How much of the financial forecasting that MLB presents to the press and government do you feel is done to leverage the public in terms of stadium development and for collective bargaining purposes?


Zimbalist: Some of it. I tend to believe that those are not the main motivations today. Of course historically the other factor has been to hold on to the anti-trust exemption, or the  presumed anti-trust exemption, when they testify to Congress. But more recently I think the strongest motivation that teams have to color their financial picture is to avoid revenue sharing. That is to say, if you can push your revenue off your baseball books onto your media books or onto your stadium books, or some other, as in the case of the Chicago Cubs onto their premium ticket company, then you can avoid some of baseball’s revenue sharing taxes. So I think there are a variety of motivations to do that, but it’s hard to believe in this day and age that Don Fehr or Gene Orza or Mike Weiner are very misled by claims of penury that either Selig issues for all baseball or individual teams issue. Because they’ve been down that road and they know the game pretty well.


BizBall: On that note about dispersal of revenues, the Yankees and Red Sox have been talking about doing a merger of TV packages. Do you think this continues to blur the line for revenue sharing purposes?

Zimbalist: Well, first of all, that story is simply the product of our idiotic media. There’s no truth to that story.

BizBall: Could you elaborate?

Zimbalist: I mean, look, what happens in a situation like that is that there are two people who are having a conversation over a drink who are connected to either the Yankees or the Red Sox, and there’s a third person there, and this person happens to hear one of them who sort of throws out this idea that they might bat around for thirty seconds or something. So that third person then calls up his friend who’s a journalist and the journalist wants to break the story so he goes out and writes the story. But I don’t think there’s any factual basis to the story. I’ve spoken to owners on both sides and they disclaim any such notions and even if you just look at it logically it’s absurd.

Number one, baseball has television territories that it would violate, and they’d have to get MLB’s permission. Number two, they’d be inviting anti-trust scrutiny from the Justice Department if they tried to combine forces and get more leverage in the cable television market. Number three, any synergies they might get that would increase their revenues would then have to be shared between the two teams. Number four, the Yankees and the Red Sox play at similar times during the day, or at the same time during the day, very often, and they have competing claims on the time.

There’s just an infinite number of complications. And number five, and perhaps most importantly, the Yankees and the Red Sox have gone out of their way to develop a classic baseball rivalry, and if they start jumping into television bed together it totally undermines the perception of that rivalry. And quite apart from personality differences that might make it a complicated thing to do, I don’t think it ever made any sense, and it’s just one journalist trying to get a jump on a story based on a silly rumor.

BizBall: Peter Angelos has made quite a lot of noise about fan attendance and cable share being diluted for the Orioles should the Montreal Expos relocate to DC or Northern VA. Do you subscribe to those arguments?

Zimbalist: Well, I think he’s correct that there would be some dilution in his television ratings and some dilution in his attendance. Whether the reductions would be 5%, 10%, or 15% in each case, I don’t know. I don’t think it would be more than 15%. But basically I would say to him, “Tough noogies.” You’ve got two substantial media markets there and  you can host two teams in those markets. I mean, you might as well have Jerry Reinsdorf come along and say, “Hey, the Cubs dilute my revenues.” And that would be true, too. So Reinsdorf might as well go to Major League Baseball and petition Bud Selig, and say, “Hey, Bud, you’re my friend. I’ve supported you. The Tribune Company really isn’t your friend. Why don’t we just eliminate the Chicago Cubs?” And to me, logically, there’s not too much difference in those two arguments. Politically it might be a little different, of course, because it’s harder to eliminate a team that’s been around for time immemorial than it is to create a new team into a market.

But, D.C. used to have a team. In fact, they used to have two different teams, and I think it’s a premier market and they ought to have a team. And whether or not Angelos ends up effecting Selig in the ultimate decision by baseball, I don’t know, but certainly I don’t think that he should.

BizBall: Buried deep within the wording of a bill before congress is verbiage that would allow sports franchises the same ability of other business to write off 100% percent of their intangible assets, such as TV revenues, on an evenly divided basis over 15 years, as opposed to the current system which only allows for half of the assets. Beyond the huge windfall for sports owners for long-term investment, is this simply a case of having all businesses treated equally?

Zimbalist: No, it’s not.

First of all, you can’t amortize goodwill; that rule has changed, so businesses don’t get to amortize or depreciate all of their assets. Secondly, look, they might go for public relations purposes and say that this is to treat sports franchises the same as other businesses but the fact of the matter is that sports franchises, which might be valued depending on the league and the team anywhere from $100 million to $1 billion, don’t have many hard assets to establish that value. The main thing that a sports franchise has is a berth in a monopoly sports league which you could call goodwill, you could call it a going concern, and if you want you can somewhat falsely attribute it to television or other media contracts.

The IRS has always historically said that television contracts are non-depreciating assets or non-amortizing assets. They are always renewed. In other words, if I buy a car, it depreciates each year, it gets a little less valuable each year, that’s a physical deterioration that happens. But if I buy a baseball team and the baseball team buys a local television contract, if you go back and look at the historical records, when that contract is over there’s always a new one! And historically it’s always been a larger one. But whether it’s larger or not, the value is pretty much ongoing. Now in some cases something might happen that’s unanticipated, and then you might have an impairment of the asset, and they ought to be able to account for an impairment of assets, but generally speaking, baseball teams and other sports teams, almost all of their value is intangible.

In contrast, if you look at a manufacturing company, most of their value is tangible. They’ve got machinery, they’ve got technology, they’ve got patents, and so on. And therefore if you allow them to amortize some of their intangible assets, it’s going to be a minority of their  overall asset value. But if you allow a sports team to amortize the intangibles, you’re basically allowing them to amortize the whole thing. So it’s different for sports than for other businesses.

And to me the more fundamental question is, what is the theoretical basis for saying there’s any depreciation at all in the tangible assets? And I don’t think there is one. And so I see it as an improper give away, and I see it as once again as kind of absurd politicking wherein you have special interests who get politicians whom they donate money to to stick it onto a bill that has nothing to do with the operation of sports franchises.

BizBall: From an economic perspective, is MLB going to be able to have sustainable and healthy franchises in existing smaller markets, and how does this impact possible relocation of franchises and/or expansion?

Zimbalist: Well, it all depends on the economic system that baseball has. If baseball has a sound revenue sharing system they can put teams in smaller markets. But it also depends in part on what you mean by smaller market. Is Portland, Oregon a smaller market because it has fewer than three million people? Well, I don’t think so. It seems to me that Portland, Oregon is perfectly capable of hosting a sports team in a league that’s properly designed. And Portland is a town that has been experiencing very good population growth and looking down the road they ought to be able to have a baseball team. As should some other cities. I guess you could argue that Nintendo should make the same argument that Angelos does: “My goodness, if you put a team in Portland there’ll be some dilution in our fanbase!” And that’s true. They’ll be some. But whether it’s 2%, 4%, or 5%, or 6%, who knows? But also, who cares? Because the people of Portland deserve a baseball team just as much as the people of Seattle do.

BizBall: I think they’re hand-wringing over this situation because it really does open up and set precedent if they pay off Angelos when he doesn’t have territorial rights to D.C. And it opens up a can of worms, like you’re saying with Howard Lincoln and Nintendo, Seattle and Portland, even though it’s 175 miles away they deem this a territorial market from a regional cable perspective and radio broadcast perspective.

Zimbalist: Look, I’ll tell you what, you have two territories for a baseball team. One is the physical territory; it used to be determined by 75 miles, now it’s defined in terms of counties.

And then you have another market--that’s the television market--that is much broader. And in fact the television markets span territories so that they bump up against each other. And therefore, they cover the whole country.

And so there’s no reason why Major League Baseball would not allocate like the whole state of Arkansas to a team, like the Houston Astros, for instance. They wouldn’t say, “Oh well, you know, it’s more than X number of miles from your ballpark and therefore you can’t have it.” No, they’re not going to leave the potential fans in Arkansas without access on local cable to watching a team.

So what they do is allocate: television markets are allocated to everybody in the United States. Therefore, whenever you contemplate adding a team you’d be interfering with somebody’s television market. And if you held that argument as decisive that, “Oh, you’re taking away part of this guy’s television market,” then you’d never be able to have expansion. Not now and not in forty years. Even when the U.S. population might be 350 million instead of 290 million. So that argument can’t possibly be a conclusive argument in my view.

BizBall: How much of the current growth in MLB is attributed to the recent honeymoon effect of new stadium development and do you see a trend in which there will be repercussions when these honeymoon periods fade?

Zimbalist: The honeymoon effect is very short-lived unless the owner is smart enough to take advantage of it.

A new stadium gives the owner an opportunity to get more revenue out of his players, and if his players generate more revenue they should be paid more. And so the smart owner says, I’m going to take advantage of my new stadium by increasing my payroll and putting a better team on the field, and getting my fans really excited. If the owner does that you can get a honeymoon effect that lasts five, six, seven, eight years.

If the owner doesn’t do that, then there’s a curiosity effect that can last two or three months, after which the fans get ticked off that the owner isn’t doing anything to improve the team. So honeymoon effects are very differential. It depends on the strengths and acumen of ownership.

That said, yes, of course, baseball has had a building renaissance, since 1991, and that renaissance has, although some teams more than others, that renaissance has generally raised attendance appreciably. And as the newness of some of these stadiums fades into the past, they won’t have that factor to boost attendance anymore. So other things being equal, yeah, that would make attendance drop a little bit.

BizBall: In your book, May the Best Team Win, you talk about how the Yankees have incentives to increase their stadium expenses, new stadia development, and a number of other areas. The last Chapter is entitled, “What is to be done?” Can you touch on this facet of the book, and tell us if any of the points within that chapter have changed since publication?

Zimbalist: You mean things that I would recommend?

BizBall: Yes.

Zimbalist: Well, I wrote that book at a time when baseball was talking about contracting by two or four teams. And I believe that as long as baseball maintains that posture, especially after a period where its revenues have been growing by 15-16% per year, that the U.S. Congress ought to go after baseball and say, “We’ve had enough. Your demand is increasing by 15% a year. If you want to reduce your output, we’re going to force you guys to have competition so that we can have an appropriate level of output.” Meaning more baseball teams rather than less baseball teams when demand is growing at 15% a year.

That’s what I believe.

And I believe in general that it would better serve U.S. fans, U.S. consumers, to have more competition in the baseball industry. But I don’t believe, at this point in time, that it’s in the cards, because baseball isn’t talking about contraction anymore, and therefore it makes more sense when talking about policy to focus on more realistic policy options.

And for me the most important thing for baseball to do is to get their revenue sharing system right. Because this year they’re going to be sharing about $280 million, top teams to the bottom teams, and it’s not going to do anything, in my view, to improve competitive balance. Because the bottom teams face this higher tax rate than the top teams. And payroll disparity has actually grown since 2002 when this new revenue sharing system was introduced.

So, I think they need to get their incentives right.

Right now the way the incentive system works in the revenue sharing system is that successful teams get penalized, and poorly performing teams are rewarded. Failure is rewarded and success is penalized. And I think you need to have a revenue sharing system that does the opposite, where teams are motivated to improve themselves. And so that would be the first thing that I would change.

Second thing that I would change, although I recognize that Bud Selig has done some good things, I don’t think baseball’s commissioner should be an owner. And I think that Selig’s  botched a lot of stuff. And so I think they need to replace Selig. I don’t think that they will, but I think they need to replace Selig, get some independent, intelligent, outside businessperson who knows a great deal about baseball, and leads the sport in a way that doesn’t suggest that there’s any conflict of interest, or that there’s any inability on the part of the commissioner to act in the best interests of baseball rather than the best interests of a coterie of owners.

BizBall: I understand that you have another book slated to be published. Can you tell us about it?

Zimbalist: Very briefly, I’m writing a book with Stefan Szymanski, who’s a British sports economist. What we’re doing is looking at the evolution of basically soccer leagues and the evolution of baseball and other closed leagues in the United States. Soccer Leagues in Europe and throughout the rest of the world are organized on an open basis and systems of promotion and relegation, where the top teams in the league get promoted to a higher level league, and the bottom teams in the league get demoted or relegated to a lower level league.

That system creates a very different pattern of incentives and fan responses than the closed system that we have in the United States, closed meaning that the existing owners determine if there will be expansion, and if there is expansion, who gets to own a team. And that creates a system of leverage and monopoly that gives teams an ability to extort large public subsidies and deprives fans in many cities of getting to have a professional team, when they warrant one, given the economic size of the city.

So, these are very, very different ways of organizing sports leagues, and they generate very different kinds of tensions and problems, and have different kinds of successes.

So what we're trying to do in the book is to explain how the systems are different, explain why they evolved the way that they did, looking at economic and political and cultural factors.

And then, finally, trying to figure out where the systems are heading, and whether the two systems can learn anything from each other.

The following interview was originally published on the SABR Business of Baseball website, and can be read here: SABR Business of Baseball Interviews Page

Interview conducted by Maury Brown on 8/9/04. Edited by Jeff Sackmann.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?