charge credit cards online free visa cash back credit card deals us bank business credit card review small business credit card processing reviews no credit credit cards to build credit credit card finder uk can i get a student credit card with no credit history capital one business credit card application status balance transfer cards for poor credit rating best zero interest credit cards 2012 store credit cards that are easy to get approved for pay firestone credit card bill online discover credit card merchant services sbi international credit card benefits no credit history check credit cards australia ge money bank credit cards care credit small online loan bad credit maurices credit card login secured credit cards after bankruptcy canada credit card credit score requirement free visa credit card number and security code 2013 chase united credit card deal payday lenders only no credit check discover student credit card designs iphone credit card reader reviews uk us bank credit card application under review bank of america credit card travel notification visa mastercard prepaid credit cards natwest corporate credit cards online jetstar credit card fees which credit card is best in india 2011 credit card debt help for veterans credit card number checker free download cabela;s master credit card trust best student credit cards with low apr credit card no credit history no deposit how to pay standard chartered credit card bill from hdfc bank how to choose a credit card singapore secured visa credit card application 0 apr credit cards on purchases best credit card interest rates canada verifone vx610 wireless credit card terminal zero interest credit card promotions tesco credit card protection policy generic credit card authorization form word apr credit card calculator uk low interest credit cards for bad credit bank of america secured credit card instant approval compare best small business credit card walmart credit cards account best credit cards for not so good credit instant online cash loans no documents south africa chase united credit card customer service number the best credit card to have now psn wallet credit card information not valid bp gas reward cards citibank secured credit card philippines united chase business credit card pay hdfc credit card bill online through debit card credit card verification process india orchard bank credit card correspondence phone number weekly pay loans pay my national city credit card online anz cash back visa gold low interest balance transfer credit card canada accept credit cards over the phone using paypal bmo us dollar credit card air miles no foreign transaction fee credit card nz how do i pay my toys r us credit card online what is the easiest credit card to get discover student open road credit card review easy fast cash loans amazon store credit card apr bank of america credit card 0 apr alertpay not accepting credit cards credit card scanners identity theft is it worth getting a loan to pay off credit cards visa signature credit card wiki first premier bank credit card for bad credit reviews credit card app iphone canada sbi credit card personal loan apply for jcpenney credit card phone number for chase business credit cards does costco accept credit cards best buy credit card no interest offers best credit card rewards for travel skim block credit card protector credit card processing comparison tool household credit card login page reward credit cards review canada best buy credit card app status get credit card numbers and cvv everyday rewards cards woolworths gift credit cards walmart credit card payments over the phone how to claim natwest credit card points advantages of accepting credit cards online what does your credit score need to be to get a best buy credit card payday loans online decision ryanair credit debit card charges can you buy a prepaid visa with a walmart credit card gnc gold card discount natwest gold credit card interest rate vanquis credit card payment line half platinum card hull usa credit card number sample credit card terminal providers singapore instant approval credit cards for fair credit phone number for first premier credit cards halifax credit card 0800 number walmart discover credit card cash advance dbs debit visa card anz platinum credit card car rental credit card business model pdf cash advance online in minutes australia credit card holder cath kidston where is the credit card number located on an american express credit card instant walmart credit card approval secured credit card for bad credit australia compare credit card machines citibank credit card online application india amazon credit card interest free period barclays credit card 0 interest no teletrack payday loans direct lenders apply online for barclays bank credit card government travel credit card application form key ring reward cards app review top credit cards in canada 2011 best business credit cards for airmiles kotak aqua credit card payday online loans reviews quick online cash loans cape town apply for student credit card wells fargo credit card payment protection insurance compensation how to get bpi credit card cash advance pin top rated credit card apps for iphone lowest fixed rate credit card interest rate american express gold credit card uk prepaid visa canada credit card reward cards for stores list low interest rate credit card canada credit card annual interest rate explained complaints against capital one credit card company use credit card to build credit rating is getting a walmart credit card a good idea non secured credit cards for bad credit canada visa cards wiki business credit cards with cashback what is credit card apr rate black card magazine usa online cash loans same day payout storing credit card information in mysql citibank virtual credit card number manual credit card machine slips bmo mastercard travel insurance valid credit card numbers with security code 2013 credit card minimum payment formula what to know when applying for credit card amazon credit card further review payday advance direct lenders bad credit cash back credit card malaysia 2013 online payday lenders only who has the lowest interest rate credit card capital one credit card uk sign in no credit card business loans credit score matters miles and more credit card swiss air best chase credit card for bad credit money saving expert best credit card for purchases credit card magnetic strip protector sleeve how to set up a small business to accept credit cards ebay change payment from credit card to paypal bank of america visa business credit cards cash back offer on icici credit cards visa credit card fees charges credit card fraud punishment illinois how to calculate credit card interest rate in excel amazon credit card payments chase slate credit card ratings check chase freedom credit card application status credit card apply online in india of bank of india barclays credit card eligibility in india bank of america cash rewards for business mastercard? credit card amazon credit card payment how to prevent credit card fraud online shopping capital credit card login page mastercard uk twitter visa disney credit card canada list of credit card numbers wikipedia apply for ge capital credit card pnc secured credit card login top 10 unsecured credit cards for bad credit are there any good credit cards for bad credit chase visa card application chase credit card rate reduction city union bank credit card online apply ny and company credit card payment address easy application for credit cards consolidating credit card debt into a loan quick cash payday loans north augusta sc new credit card apply in india allahabad bank india card master international credit card four square credit card app abn amro credit card online payment india uob corporate credit card singapore paypal credit card payment php pay loans uk best payday loan no credit check best interest free credit card transfers how to activate hsbc debit visa card lowering credit card interest rates hdfc credit card travel offers credit card processing application alaska airline credit card deals best credit card to get are credit card balance transfers bad for your credit credit card logos paypal pre approved credit cards capital one 5 what are some things to look for when choosing a credit card best secured credit card for no credit history company credit cards with rewards credit card 0 balance transfer malaysia reducing credit card debt budget chase credit cards for students cash advance loans citibank malaysia online credit card application best buy credit cards online bill pay icici hpcl platinum credit card benefits credit card settlement process diagram prepaid reloadable credit cards walmart credit card credit limit credit score gold credit card travel insurance harris county gold card application best secured credit card after bankruptcy discharge best credit cards after bankruptcy 2013 bank of america credit card payment zip code payday advance loans in augusta ga application status for citibank credit card best fixed rate credit cards 2013 credit card authorisation form template australia get a credit card instantly with bad credit is it bad to sign up for a credit card and not use it do i need a credit card to sign up for an apple id a review of islamic credit card models in malaysia capital city credit card login how do i combine all my credit cards into one how to redeem hdfc world credit card reward points cash advance ukraine santander 123 credit card instant decision working fake credit card information santander 0 percent credit card citibank business credit card contact free visa credit card number 2013 credit card number and cvv number free balance transfer credit card offers business credit cards canada rbc advance america can;t pay online credit card best credit cards 2013 for students halifax credit card transfer to bank account where can i apply visa credit card apple itunes credit card declined random credit card number and name icici bank international credit card best usaa credit card for students best credit card apr credit card 0 balance transfer iphone credit card case amazon direct 1 hour payday loan lender types of best buy credit cards low rate credit card offers top 50 credit cards online virtual terminal credit card processing uk wells fargo credit card cash advance chase 0 balance transfer credit card for international students singapore best international credit card canada td canada trust cash back credit card credit card cash advance fee wells fargo pnb credit card helpline no visa credit card insurance on purchases new credit card fees hdfc credit card offers for mobiles o interest credit cards ireland alaska airlines credit card canada review using personal credit card for business travel icici credit card rewards points catalogue no annual fee credit card singapore bank of america credit cards rewards program small business credit card machine portable visa business credit card limit barclays bank how to get a credit card generic credit card release authorization form e application for sbi credit card shoppers drug mart credit card points 3 most popular credit cards southwest air credit card deals us bank credit card processing charges low interest credit card with no balance transfer fee instant approval credit card for poor credit im 18 how do i get a credit card can i get a personal loan with bad credit and no bank account best reward credit card canada 2012 halifax student credit card online top 10 credit card issuers 2012 generate us credit card number toys r us credit card ge phone number no fee rewards credit cards canada first premier credit card online login payday loans online no credit check instant approval uk 0 interest rate credit card australia bank credit card interest rates credit card for no credit sears kmart credit card iphone credit card reader australia genuine bad credit loans uk pre approved credit card offers forum chase united credit card review visa credit card search online prepaid credit card best bad credit loans no fees what is the easiest unsecured credit card to get with bad credit whats the average credit card apr bad credit car finance warrington best buy credit card activation best cashback credit cards uae most secure credit card companies visa credit card usa login easiest way to get a credit card with no credit dept store credit cards for fair credit capital one balance transfer card what credit cards can i apply for with average credit how do i get a cash advance on my bank of america credit card merchant credit card fees wiki visa rewards card login mastercard prepaid credit cards spain how does credit card balance transfers work american express corporate credit card credit check nhs black card amazon best no annual fee visa card in canada best cashback credit cards 2012 malaysia intuit canada credit card processing consolidating credit card debt canada i need a credit card to help rebuild my credit axis bank credit card review india bad credit bank accounts lloyds icici platinum credit card online application who is liable to pay advance tax in india business credit cards best rewards programs horizon credit card number top credit card payment processors cash reward credit card comparison credit card validator free download square iphone credit card service standard chartered credit card bank india wachovia wells fargo credit card rewards cheap cash advances payday loans chase credit card interest refund where do i send my belk credit card payment opening and closing department store credit cards easy credit cards to apply for online credit score for best buy credit card approval capital one secured credit card business sbi platinum card annual fee can credit card companies garnish your wages in florida how to get an unsecured credit card with bad credit icici bank credit card statement different types of citibank credit cards virtual credit card prepaid paypal who owns visa credit card company capital one credit card online account prepaid credit card visa mbna manchester united credit card icici credit card online payment through sbi debit card best credit card deal blog visa card protection on debit cards city bank credit card payment through billdesk bad credit payday loans direct lenders credit card student australia 0 interest balance transfer credit cards australia what is cash advance fee in hdfc credit card mastercard credit card protection student visa credit cards canada can u get a credit card with bad credit fake visa credit card numbers that work walmart credit card frauds low intrest credit cards bank credit card offers credit card logos vector files incipio iphone credit card case bank of america credit card travel protection best travel rewards cards 2012 instant credit card icici eligibility free virtual credit cards online compare icici bank credit cards best rewards credit card spg what is cash back offer in credit cards wireless credit card scanner theft visa credit card exchange rate calculator mastercard exchange rate bmo should you consolidate your credit card debt barclays business credit card limit best visa credit card offers credit cards with high gas rewards rewards credit card for bad credit prepaid visa card canada get one western union gold card uk apply credit card online axis bank chase disney credit card services bdo credit card application online philippines business credit card comparison australia does western union accept credit cards to send money hsbc credit card apply philippines title loans online no credit check citifinancial credit card payment address low interest rate credit cards no annual fee how to accept credit cards small business australia best buy credit card credit check credit cards for very bad credit with no deposit credit cards 0 balance transfer no fee hdfc credit card bank offers verizon wireless credit card terminal reloadable prepaid credit cards in canada unsecured business credit card bad credit loans for military with bad credit and no credit check uk credit cards with travel insurance can you use a personal credit card for business expenses credit card application declined reasons philippines i want to apply for a maurices credit card credit card comparisons chart citibank credit card payment processing time how long does it take to receive pnc secured credit card prepaid credit card bank transfer manhattan standard chartered credit card tyvek credit card protector sleeves what;s the best credit card for no credit best reward credit cards 2011 australia hdfc credit card payment status check compare travel credit cards canada free credit card numbers that work 2013 with cvv and expiration date axis bank credit card reward points for platinum card cash advances payday loans no credit check non 3d secure credit card find lowest rate credit cards my sears credit card login transfer credit card balance from one person to another free credit card report annual apply for a sears canada credit card remove credit card on file ebay cancel virgin credit card online payday loan online best credit card for travel rewards no annual fee apply for unsecured credit cards for bad credit halifax credit card minimum monthly payment southwest rapid rewards business credit card how to activate sbi platinum credit card features of axis bank credit cards 0 percent credit card deals uk tesco credit card interest free period how do cash advances work on credit cards credit limit increase capital one credit card lifetime free credit cards in india 2012 how to get a citibank credit card walmart credit card status check payday lenders no brokers uk hsbc credit card 0 balance transfer free credit cards with no annual fee how to settle credit card debt nationwide credit card deals for existing customers get credit card with bad credit no deposit hdfc credit card charges for late payment credit cards with high cash back for gas guaranteed bad credit mortgage loans best buy application for credit card halifax credit card transfer deals interest free credit card offers 12 months sbi credit card application process credit cards student credit cards with no credit instant approval td visa gold cash back quickbooks credit card processing 0 percent apr credit cards 12 months hdfc credit cards offers in india zero percent interest credit cards offers orchard bank credit cards for poor credit zero interest credit card calculator walmart visa debit gift card international credit card icici bank what kind of credit card should i get with no credit huge credit card fraud bust in new jersey buy anonymous prepaid credit card hdfc corporate credit card status credit card bank rakyat vanilla visa card canada balance american airlines platinum credit card benefits best visa credit cards with rewards first time credit card holder no credit bank of america credit card visa signature hdfc credit card offer on flipkart chase credit card balance transfer to checking account
Home Biz of Baseball - Interviews Interview - Rudy Telscher - Attorney, CDM Fantasy Sports

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1180 guests online

Atom RSS

Interview - Rudy Telscher - Attorney, CDM Fantasy Sports PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
Written by Maury Brown   
Thursday, 08 November 2007 04:45
Rudy Telscher

In court cases involving professional sports, there may not be one in recent memory that will have the impact that CBC Marketing Inc. and the MLB Players’ Association and MLB Advanced Media is currently engaged in. CBC owns CDM Fantasy Sports, a fantasy sports company at the heart of the legal case.

In the simplest of terms, the case revolves around how the fantasy sports industry is able to use statistics in conjunction with MLB player names. The “Fantasy Stats” case, as it has been coined, will impact how rights of privacy, the First Amendment, and contractual obligation is interpreted. MLB, and other professional sports leagues that have filed supporting briefs, believe that by using a player’s name with their statistics, the player is being exploited. CBC has countered that name with the statistics is information protected by the First Amendment.

It also impacts revenues for both fantasy sports companies, and professional sports leagues looking to capitalize on the fantasy game frenzy. Online fantasy sports now constitute a billion-dollar industry, with between 15 and 18 million unique players participating every year in fantasy baseball or football, according to the Fantasy Sports Trade Association.

Rudy Telscher, with Harness, Dickey & Pierce, P.L.C. is CBC’s attorney in the case. Given the impact of the case (read from our Fantasy Stats Case section), the Biz of Baseball caught up with Telscher for this interview. It should be noted that the case is still not fully closed, and that the Business of Sports Network would like to present the opposing view of the case by way of the MLBPA and MLBAM to provide a balanced view of this important case. – Maury Brown

Maury Brown for the Business of Sports Network: The C.B.C. v MLBAM/MLBPA case has been referred to in some circles as "David vs. Goliath". How were you approached on the case, and what are the intriguing aspects of it?

Telscher quote on case being David v. GoliathTelscher: There is no question that this was a classic David vs. Goliath. Major League Baseball Players Association is a wealthy organization that staffed the case with multiple large national firms. The Players Association took a very aggressive approach, insisting that our client simply get out of the business. Further, if our client had lost, it would have meant that about 100-200 fantasy companies would have gone out of business. These are the same companies that helped build this industry to what it is today.

Bizball: With the 2-1 one ruling in favor to uphold the lower court's summary judgment, you gain yet another victory for CBC. Yet, even the judges ruling in favor raised concerns regarding CBC contractual obligations being broken. If for some reason the Supreme Court were to say that the case was certworthy, do you feel that the first amendment would continue to trump that aspect?

Telscher: The 8th Circuit's ruling is a major victory for our client, the 100 plus companies that built the fantasy industry and continue to run businesses that provide fantasy services (they would have gone out of business had we lost), and the fans who will not have to pay monopoly pricing and will greater alternative game formats that necessarily arise in a highly competitive market (imagine how few alternatives a consumer would have in the car market if there were only one or two manufacturers).

Telscher on First AmendmentThe 8th Circuit was unanimous that the First Amendment trumps player rights of publicity. Judge Colloton only dissented on the contract issue. That issue is specific only to whether CBC had the right to challenge MLB's rights, not whether the First Amendment trumps player rights of publicity. That issue is irrelevant to the overall issue and those companies that did not sign contracts with MLB.

I think the only reason the Supreme Court would take this case is if it is interested in the interplay between the First Amendment and state law rights of publicity. It has only decided one case in that area before and that was back in the 1970s. I doubt the contract issue will be enticing to it, especially given that the 8th Circuit ruled on state contract interpretation principles and not under federal preemption (the Supreme Court case of Lear v. Adkins).

Bizball: Was there a conscious effort by C.B.C. to sue before being sued, knowing that in doing so Missouri state law would come into play as opposed to New York state law?

CBC did not pick Missouri because of any legal difference. When the Players Association refused to grant it a license to operate its fantasy games, it had no choice but to sue to have its rights declared. CBC is based in St. Louis and that is why St. Louis was picked as the place to bring the lawsuit.

Bizball: Many have asked what the difference is between how information on baseball cards differs from the information that is provided through fantasy sports companies. Can you describe the difference?

Telscher: I think that fantasy’s use of baseball statistics is more akin to a newspaper because newspapers and fantasy provide and use the mass statistics for all athletes, not just some as with baseball cards. That said, baseball cards provide the same information as newspapers and I would think that baseball card manufacturers should receive the same First Amendment protections for their information products as do newspapers. I would not be surprised to see baseball and other sports get challenged on this point.

Bizball: While the case has focused on statistics and their use, the real issue at hand has been about the use of player names in association with the statistics. From your point of view, is that truly the case, or would any case involving information that is readily available via a host of mediums by way of boxscores, etc. never find the light of a courtroom?

Telscher: I interpret your question to be whether the resolved issue in this case has broader implications. In our case, the 8th Circuit affirmed the district court's decision that the use of publicly available statistics in fantasy games, even though it uses, by definition, the names of the players is protected by the First Amendment and supersedes any rights of publicity that the players might otherwise have. Similar situations already exist. For example, asking questions about the movies of Brad Pitt or Jennifer Aniston involve the use of their names and associated data/accomplishments in a game for profit as used in Trivial Pursuit and Jeopardy. So does Las Vegas' practice of betting on the accomplishments of individual players performances during a specific game. The broader holding of the case is legitimately interpreted to be that use of historical information that relates to famous people in any way they see fit (there may be some limits depending on individual fact patterns) is protected by the First Amendment.

Bizball: What preparations, if any, are you and C.B.C. doing now that the 8th Circuit has affirmed the lower court ruling?

Telscher: The Players Association and Advanced Media (the owners group) have both filed petitions for rehearing and rehearing en banc. These petitions are rarely granted. After that, the Players Association can file a petition for Supreme Court review, which is also rarely granted. Until it exhausts those final avenues, the case is not final.  When the process is final, all of the fantasy industry will be able to operate fantasy games without the Players Association interfering.

Telscher on NFLBizball: If MLBAM/MLBPA decides to drop the case, or the Appeals Court or Supreme Court decide not to take the case, how will it impact the fantasy sports industry?

Telscher: The 8th Circuit decision stands for the proposition that use of player statistics in fantasy is protected under the First Amendment. MLB would be bound by the decision and could not ever relitigate it. The implications of the decision extend to any fantasy sport though. The only caveat is that the NFL could sue some company in another circuit, for example, the 2nd Circuit in New York, and as a matter of federalism, the 2nd Circuit is not technically bound by the 8th Circuit's decision. It would be possible, although not likely in my view, that the 2nd Circuit could resolve the First Amendment issue differently than the 8th Circuit. If the latter did occur, however, the odds of the Supreme Court taking the case (split in the Circuits) would go way up. Given that the 8th Circuit's decision is consistent with some similar type cases (Cardtoons, Gionfriddo, and ETW), I think the odds are that other Circuits will follow the 8th Circuit's lead, but there are no guarantees.

Bizball: Do you think that those companies that have licenses with MLBAM may now reconsider?

Telscher:  Absolutely. Whether they can back out of those agreements and on what terms may be governed by the actual provisions, but most contracts would provide the ability to exit. Further, most contracts of this nature have relatively short terms and will therefore likely expire in the next year or so in any event. Given the ruling, I doubt that many, if any, companies will renew their contracts in the event that they cannot terminate immediately.

Telscher quote on monopolyBizball: Lastly, this will become key case law at some point, impacting not only Major League Baseball, but a host of other professional sports. What are your philosophical views on the outcome of C.B.C. v. MLBAM?

Telscher: The reasoning of professional players regarding why fans should pay them to play fantasy and why they should monopolize this industry is because they contend that their rights of publicity are being violated. Rights of publicity are designed to put more money into the pockets of professional athletes and famous people more generally. There are times when that is fair, for example, when a famous person is used to advertise and promote a product. With fantasy sports, however, consumers are not led to believe that professional athletes are endorsing the fantasy games. Everyone plainly knows that they are not. Thus, there is no legitimate reason to think that consumers should have to pay monopoly pricing to play fantasy sports, no more so than professional athletes should be able to charge for the use of their statistics in newspapers, which would drive up the cost of newspapers. Professional athletes played no part in building the fantasy industry and they should not be able to come in 25 years later and take over an industry that they did not build.

Interview conducted and edited by Maury Brown


Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?