credit cards for credit scores below irs form free credit card download random number generators immediate use all bad credit card offers pre approval amazon cards against humanity rules good store credit gas cards for bad credit fake credit card numbers and security code credit card offers the best credit cards for bad credit unsecured credit cards easy best business secured credit cards gas cards for bad which is worse bad credit or no credit apply for a belk credit card security code on visa free amazon gift card generator 2014 pay wells fargo wells fargo jewelry advantage credit card payment all types of the matrix credit card reviews how to make a fake credit card number and cvv credit cards with 0 0% 0% apr for 2 years chevy chase applied bank secured credit cards real where is the mastercard security code costco american express bad credit card department store charge unsecured credit cards for bad credit aventium hsbc best buy credit card login in wells fargo free credit card generator download 4.0 capital one credit card credit score requirements apply for a 5000 credit card with bad credit opt out of american virgin airlines credit card offers 5k highest credit card limit bank of america what if i do not activate my credit card credit cards for credit scores below 2015 cls 550 easiest department store best credit card 2013 offers credit cards for really guaranteed bad credit unsecured personal loans best guaranteed secured credit cards with bad credit free cc franklin spell checker online ge money bank ge money paypal plus credit card login sears credit card yahoo customer service phone # best secured credit card best cards for bad credit 2013 valid credit card numbers with cvv for testing do store how much does paying off credit cards help credit score credit cards for people with no credit history at all good credit card best credit card offers for bad credit what the best credit easy credit card to apply for fake credit cards play play monopoly with real money citibank online visa joint credit card application fake credit card numbers that work with security code and expiration date best credit card for low income earners in india a real credit cvv penis enlargement that works valid credit card information with cvv webmd health corp apply sears capital one credit card puerto rico how to get a business credit get credit card with poor high risk unsecured credit secured credit cards to rebuild best credit cards microsoft office for small business 2013 unemployed student business credit cards instant approval fake credit card numbers that work with security code hacked credit card numbers and security codes balance transfer credit card offers for bad credit fake credit card information and number one free valid credit card with cvv super teacher fossil target credit card application free canadian guaranteed approval credit cards free paypal amazon gift card generator no survey visa credit card bad credit no deposit credit cards with low rates for cash advances high limit unsecured credit cards for bad credit free 2013 stolen credit card with cvv2 generator fake credit card numbers that have money on them status on my alaska united delta airlines credit card application guaranteed secured credit new credit cards for poor pay haband sear sears credit card online account access top secured credit how to use a credit card to build credit samsung security code number unsecured credit cards for 600 credit score valid credit card security code number bad credit loans instant decision map of australia free reloadable virtual credit cards does chase bank which banks offer secured credit cards fake working credit card numbers with security code paypal fees for ebay sellers american express for fair credit score valid security code chase verify card number free credit cards numbers that how does paypal work on ebay when selling good credit cards for people with no credit history what is the best credit card for loans for someone with no apply for home home depot credit card login payments ebay australia paypal sign in 10 best credit accepting credit cards for small business working credit cards with cvv walmart credit card numbers with cvv and exp. date o percent credit top credit cards for balance transfers free valid visa credit card information all types of matrix kohl's credit card payment online high limit credit card best credit card offers for bad credit wells fargo credit card generator 2014 download can u use horizon gold credit gift card for gas only bbva credit nlop download walmart prepaid visa debit cards green dot is home depot bk argentina argentina vs spain friendly how to get a credit card with bad credit history in australia real credit card numbers and security codes that work online 2013 itunes please enter valid security code utalk walmart at&t phone numbers customer service kmart kohl's ikea credit card application online real free valid credit card account numbers make a fake credit card number and security code easiest unsecured credit card for bad credit google play store does roku require credit card best credit cards for government small business start up loans instant approval gas capital one credit cards for bad credit list of all guaranteed instant approval bad credit credit cards
Home All Articles Analysis: Fantasy Stats Case Appeal Heard

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 797 guests online

Atom RSS

Analysis: Fantasy Stats Case Appeal Heard PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
Articles & Opinion
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 15 June 2007 07:02

The Biz of Baseball

The following is analysis from Maury Brown, a sports business analyst for the Business of Sports Network  

Yesterday, oral arguments in the appeal of CBC Marketing and Distribution v. MLB Advanced Media took place before three judges for the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in St. Louis. The landmark case revolves around CDM Fantasy Sports’ (who was then owned by CBC Marketing) use of player statistics without a license from MLB Advanced Media. MLBAM and the MLBPA reached a $50 million agreement which, “provides MLBAM the exclusive rights to use, and to sublicense to others, Major League baseball player group rights for the development and creation of on-line games, all other online content, including fantasy baseball and interactive games, as well as all wireless applications including cell-phone enabled games.”

CBC sued MLBAM and the MLBPA arguing that they should be able to conduct the business of fantasy baseball games for-profit without a license and use player names and their associated statistics.

A judgment in US District Court in 2006 agreed.

Attorneys representing the MLB Players Association (MLBPA) and MLB Advanced Media (MLBAM) are urging the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to reverse the lower court judgment from US District Court Judge Mary Ann Medler from August of last year (see the opinion handed down by the court as well as the conclusion here on The Biz of Sports).

The appellant brief filed by the MLBPA and MLBAM reads in part (read the entire brief, along with its associated addendum here):

CBC’s conduct violates Missouri’s publicity rights law, and enforcement of those rights does not affect expressive activity or violate the First Amendment. At the very least, disputed issues of material fact precluded summary judgment for CBC. Alternatively, no federal statute addresses publicity rights and thus federal law does not preempt enforcement of CBC’s state-law contract obligations.

(To listen to the court proceedings, as well as read a partial transcript, select Read More)

Virginia Seitz, representing the MLBPA in oral arguments (listen to the oral arguments from yesterday here), urged the court to reverse the ruling based on right of publicity, stating that while statistics themselves could be used, once an MLB player is associated to those statistics, it breaks with the right of publicity and therefore is not protected by the First Amendment as outlined in the lower court’s judgment.

The judges seemed to be skeptical of that argument when addressing counsel for the MLBPA.

In a sharp exchange between Chief Judge James Luken and Seitz, Judge Luken said:

“So, now we have a limitation (referring to the use of associating a player to their statistics), and now I come around to, ‘This isn’t about statistics’ -- the basic war of the brief .

‘This is about names,' you say. ‘This is about statistics,’ they say.

And I understand the practicality of the war because the statistics are in the public domain.  And it seems to me, it’s clearly a use of public information to figure out that if you’re going to have an ongoing fantasy sports league over the life of a real professional sports league – clearly a collateral market – you have to have an opening set of statistics and evolving statistics that will allow competition and trades and so forth.

And so where do you get those statistics?

Well you can’t take the 1923 Philadelphia Athletics because that doesn’t evolve over a season. So you take these statistics that are in the public domain.

And as I translate the argument in this case.... ‘Well, we won’t argue with that (referring to the use of statistics without player association), but don’t you dare put a name next to those statistics.’

Well, of course that’s ridiculous.

So you are saying that this collateral market can be monopolized by your clients. The statistics – the public statistics – cannot be marshaled and be used for another kind of game without your clients getting a share of the action.”

Seitz then replied:

“Those statistics can appear in newspapers. Those statistics can be published on websites. But what cannot be done is have a player identity – a name – be used as a game piece for identification.”

Judge Luken shot back:

“The only identification is identifying the statistics so that this group of evolving statistics for the second baseman can be followed.”

The name is only to identify the statistics. It’s not to steal the identity of the second baseman.”

Seitz responded:

“The only reason these game are valuable and marketable is precisely because these are major league baseball player names attached to those statistics. If you used ‘Player A’, ‘Player B’, no one would be interested in playing the game. The game is interesting precisely because people feel they are owning and managing real major league players.

In summarizing his points later, Judge Luken said, “Since this is completely tangential to Major League Baseball, and the success of Major League Baseball, I don’t understand where that success and that identity, gives the players – at least I’m having trouble seeing – how it gives the players the right to monopolize an entirely separate entertainment industry.”

Rudy Telscher, lead counsel for CBC said during his 20 minutes that, “There’s not any affidavit from players who say they feel like they have been damaged,” referring to the fantasy baseball gaming industry. He then went on to say that the Phillies front office participated in playing fantasy baseball actively.

Telscher argued that fantasy baseball – in its various forms – have been played for years prior to the dispute between MLBAM and CBC.

“The only thing that my clients did was to create software to automate it.”

Reached for comment on Friday, Charlie Weigert, Vice-President of CDM Marketing said that there was extra pressure knowing that if the case remains in CDM's favor that it will create case law, and leave a lasting legacy.

As to how long he might be willing to pursue the case, Weigert stood behind his convictions.

"I’ll pursue the case as far as it goes," Weigert said. "Hopefully this decision will produce a final opinion and the decision will be as strong as the lower court decision, so if they try to appeal this higher, they are rejected."

A ruling on the appeal is expected from the three-judge panel in three to six months. 

Maury Brown is the founder and president of The Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball and The Biz of Football (full launch coming in July). He is a contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and can be contacted here. 



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?